3 arguments companies use to pay you less - and how to respond


Hi Reader,

This week, we wanted to share with you three common (but poor) arguments companies use during salary negotiations 👇

1️⃣ “If we give you the max salary available now, we won’t have room to increase it later”

▶ Translation: “We don’t have a sustainable way to reward employees other than pay below market now so we can pay a bit more later.”

▶Your move: Ask for the max salary now, stating that it will keep you more motivated than making less money now but more later (and hence less money overall).

Waiting on compensation with the hope of future raises rarely pays off. If the company values you, they should provide a competitive salary now—one that reflects your skills and contributions right from the start.

2️⃣ “The hiring manager [or the recruiter or someone else involved with the job offer] is on vacation”

▶Translation: We hope that you will take that as a reason to not negotiate so as not to bother the decision makers.

▶Your move: Negotiate without factoring it in at all that someone is out of office. It’s the company’s responsibility to manage your job application in a timely manner and not lose you to a competing offer.

Companies who value strong candidates don’t risk losing them over internal delays. If they’re serious about hiring you, they’ll prioritize your offer over temporary scheduling conflicts.

3️⃣ “We can’t give you more money because we aim to pay equitably across the team”

▶Translation: We care about equitability when it means paying everyone below market. But if you negotiate strategically and/or have another job offer, we will set aside equitability and do everything we can to win you over.

▶Your move: Acknowledge and applaud their equitability strategy but keep negotiating regardless.

Market dynamics take precedence over a company’s compensation philosophy (assuming they’re not just saying it to begin with) - i.e. if you have a better offer, they’ll pay more to attract the right talent.

If they need to pay you more to win you over, they could then pay everyone else in the team a bit more too then to maintain equitability, no?

🧳 Ready to get the money left on the table?

If you're job searching or expecting an upcoming negotiation, schedule a free consultation call with us here and get real-time support on how to deal with situations exactly like these.

Best,
Gerta & Alex
Co-founders of YourNegotiations.com

Hi, we’re Gerta & Alex. 👫
We’re Harvard, MIT, LinkedIn, and Instagram alums and we share negotiation tips to help you
negotiate job offers or business deals. Have an upcoming negotiation? Book a call with Alex
here!

548 Market St, No. 922375, San Francisco, CA 94104
Unsubscribe · Preferences

YourNegotiations.com Newsletter

Gerta & Alex are the founders of YourNegotiations.com, where they help executives and mid-career professionals negotiate job offers and business deals. Their backgrounds span tech (LinkedIn, Meta / Instagram, Salary.com), biotech (Sanofi), the US Air Force, venture capital, and building venture-backed companies. They're Harvard, MIT, and Wharton alums and have helped hundreds of clients add on average $100K and up to $1.7M to their compensation packages.

Read more from YourNegotiations.com Newsletter

Hi Reader, More from our Gentle Power Podcast conversation with Mia Smithson, a renowned tech industry recruiter who's interviewed more than 5000 people and hired more than 400. She shared some of her top tips in this past newsletter, where we covered why salary market data isn't helpful for negotiations and why whoever says the number first loses the negotiation. Today, we want to cover another question we always get: When the recruiter wants details about your other offer, how much should...

Hi Reader, Let’s say something uncomfortable happens at work or you’re seeing repeated incidents by a manager or co-workers that’s leaving you feeling off. You’re noticing off comments, inappropriate behavior, or in some cases, straight-up harassment or discrimination. You realize it might be important to document such cases, perhaps to protect yourself in the event you have a contentious departure from the company. But what are you legally allowed to do? Can you screenshot a Slack thread, or...

Hi Reader, This week on the Gentle Power Podcast (gentlepowerpodcast.com), we sat down with Mia Smithson, a renowned tech industry recruiter who has interviewed more than 5,000 people and hired more than 400. Amongst many achievements throughout her career, Mia joined a startup as its founding recruiter when it was around 50 people and helped grow it to a workforce of 700 across seven countries. Today, she is recruiting at a frontier AI company that hires 30 to 50 people every month. In this...