The first offer is almost never the final (and our podcast imperfections)


Hi Reader,

We’re back with another episode of our newly minted podcast, Gentle Power—and we’re embracing all the imperfections that come with starting something brand new. In this week’s behind-the-scenes:

  1. We accidentally recorded half an episode with the mic on mute. But we decided to “ship” the good half anyway rather than throw it all away because it wasn’t perfect.
  2. Design magic from the universe: A former colleague showed up at just the right time to build our logo and automate our systems for free. And yes, we’re still pinching ourselves.
  3. The negotiation tip you must remember: The first offer is rarely the best and final offer.

Read on for all the details, plus why you never want to share your preferred salary number—or even a range—before you see the company’s offer.

Behind the Scenes: Shipping Imperfectly

We’ve been hyper-focused on perfecting our second podcast episode.

But between microphone mishaps and re-shooting intros, we nearly fell into the trap of “let’s wait ‘til everything is flawless.”

This will probably sound familiar to many of you.

Here’s our big takeaway: putting things out there (even imperfectly) is how you learn.

Whether it’s publishing our imperfect episode, launching a small business, or negotiating your salary, you can’t wait for perfect conditions if you want real progress.

Yes, you can get a better offer even if you don’t have another offer.

Yes, you can get a raise even if you haven’t exceeded expectations every single month.

Yes, you can apply to your dream job, or any job, even if you don’t check all of the boxes.

Our Website & Living Proof the Universe Has Your Back

When we launched YourNegotiations.com, we were drowning in to-dos: website, branding, back-end automations, you name it.

Enter Derek: a former colleague of Alex’s and a Director of Design at Instagram who happened to be starting a new design agency, Curious Club.

He offered free work for small businesses in his first month—and we landed a gorgeous website and the iconic Y/N logo you see on our site.

The Y/N stands for “Your Negotiations” and hints at the yes-or-no moments in a negotiation—but, as you may know by now, we approach negotiations a lot more collaboratively, trying to expand the pie and finding win-win opportunities for all parties involved.

We repaid the favor by helping a family member of his negotiate a new job offer, resulting in a substantial boost.

Win-win at its finest!

Negotiation Tip: The First Offer Is Almost Never their Final Offer

Companies nearly always leave wiggle room for candidates who negotiate or have competing offers.

That initial number they show you?

It’s rarely their absolute max—which is why you always want to negotiate.

Even if you *think* you don’t have any leverage. Even if you’re happy with the first offer.

Why leave money on the table?

And in certain roles, it may be a red flag if you *don’t* negotiate the first offer.

Negotiating is such a critical business skill that taking the first offer without negotiating at all might concern your future employer that you shy away from uncomfortable conversations.

But the quickest way to leave money on the table is to reveal your number (or range) first.

That’s because:

  • If you reveal a number below the top of their true budget (which is not the same as the publicly posted salary range), you’d be leaving money on the table.
  • If you reveal a number above their budget, you risk looking out of touch, entitled, or overpriced.

And sharing your range is essentially sharing your number because the lowest number in your range tells the employer that you’re willing to accept that.

Our advice:

Let them share a number first.

Then you can decide how to counter.

We dive deeper into these strategies in this week’s episode of Gentle Power.

You’ll also catch a fun segment on how moving forward (even after a blooper) is how we stay sane while running a small business together.

And if you’re on the brink of a crucial negotiation—job offer or otherwise—book a free consultation call with us.

We’ll help you figure out if there’s more wiggle room than meets the eye.

Until next time—here’s to shipping imperfectly, asking confidently, and never settling for less than you’re worth.

Gerta & Alex
Co-founders, YourNegotiations.com

P.S. For more tips and real-life scripts, grab our free worksheets at YourNegotiations.com​.

Hi, we’re Gerta & Alex. 👫
We’re Harvard, MIT, LinkedIn, and Instagram alums and we share negotiation tips to help you
negotiate job offers or business deals. Have an upcoming negotiation? Book a call with Alex
here!

548 Market St, No. 922375, San Francisco, CA 94104
Unsubscribe · Preferences

YourNegotiations.com Newsletter

Gerta & Alex are the founders of YourNegotiations.com, where they help executives and mid-career professionals negotiate job offers and business deals. Their backgrounds span tech (LinkedIn, Meta / Instagram, Salary.com), biotech (Sanofi), the US Air Force, venture capital, and building venture-backed companies. They're Harvard, MIT, and Wharton alums and have helped hundreds of clients add on average $100K and up to $1.7M to their compensation packages.

Read more from YourNegotiations.com Newsletter

Hi Reader, This week on the Gentle Power Podcast, we spoke with Soumya Maya, who's building an AI product to help people making career pivots. She started out in architecture, spent a decade moving across different industries, and most recently worked in product management at edtech startups before leaving a few months ago to support career changers. Most people who switch industries assume they’re starting over, that a new field means a weaker hand when it comes to compensation, level, and...

Hi Reader, We recently published our podcast interview with Gerta's negotiation professor from MIT, Ofer Sharone (full episode: YouTube | Spotify | Apple). We covered a lot with Professor Sharone, more than fit in one newsletter, so we're picking up where the first newsletter left off. That first newsletter was about negotiation mindset. Today, we're going to get more tactical: why it's important to dig for why a company picked you, whether you should name a number, and the concept of...

Hi Reader, This week on the Gentle Power Podcast, we cover the uncomfortable negotiations that start after you're hired: resetting expectations with a peer, giving a co-worker constructive feedback, telling a direct report they’re underperforming. Our guest is Amanda Gustafson, who coaches leaders through these kinds of conversations. She took a winding path to get here, from a physics degree to running a theater in Troy, Michigan at 23, to a master's in psychology, to a stint as a dean of...