“Best and Final Offer?” Not Necessarily True


Hi Reader,

Ever heard “this is our best and final offer” before you’ve even countered? In this week’s Gentle Power episode (Youtube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts), we explain why that phrase is usually just another move. We also unpack the real limits on rounds of back-and-forth, show how one client added six figures onto a “non-negotiable” package, and outline tactics for fixed pay-band roles in government, academia, and teaching. And because every negotiation happens in real life, here’s what ours looked like recently:

Behind The Mic: Tirana Edition

A sudden loss in our family took us to Tirana, Albania. Despite the circumstances, we filled our hearts with non-stop cuddles with grandma and our baby twin cousins—all the while running late-night Zoom calls on west coast time from halfway across the world.

Huge thank you to our United Airlines pilot friend, Alan, who slipped us onto United’s standby list and saved us thousands on next-day flights. It’s great to have close friends in (sky)-high places.

Now back to our regularly scheduled negotiations programming:

How To Actually Get The Best And Final Offer

In our latest podcast episode, we debunk the usual “dead-end” myths, and walk through the real tactics that keep the conversation going until you’ve truly reached the end of the negotiation road. Negotiation isn’t over when they say it is - it’s over when the signs are unmistakable. Here’s how to know:

  • There’s no magic “round limit.” Keep asking until you hit unmistakable pushback, but always with tact and professionalism.
  • Spot the true stop sign. “Best & final” typically sticks when it lands with zero follow-ups - otherwise, there could be more wiggle room.
  • Treat the first offer as a suggestion. “Our first offer is final” is almost never true - one client still pulled in a six-figure bump.
  • Fixed bands don’t end the comp conversation. When salary is capped, pivot to perks: relocation, stipends, additional vacation days, or even a sign-on as a gesture of goodwill.
  • Decode recruiter moods. Counterintuitively, an aggressive recruiter does not necessarily mean you will NOT get a better offer. And a very sweet recruiter does not necessarily mean you WILL get a better offer.

Tune into our episode here (Youtube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts) when you’re ready for the full play-by-play, and don’t forget to download our printable cheatsheet at YourNegotiations.com to practice what to say before you begin your negotiations!

Warmly,

Gerta & Alex
Co-founders, YourNegotiations.com

P.S. If you refer a friend who becomes a client, we’ll send you $500 as a thank-you. Just reply to this email and cc them.

Hi, we’re Gerta & Alex. 👫
We’re Harvard, MIT, LinkedIn, and Instagram alums and we share negotiation tips to help you
negotiate job offers or business deals. Have an upcoming negotiation? Book a call with Alex
here!

548 Market St, No. 922375, San Francisco, CA 94104
Unsubscribe · Preferences

YourNegotiations.com Newsletter

Gerta & Alex are the founders of YourNegotiations.com, where they help executives and mid-career professionals negotiate job offers and business deals. Their backgrounds span tech (LinkedIn, Meta / Instagram, Salary.com), biotech (Sanofi), the US Air Force, venture capital, and building venture-backed companies. They're Harvard, MIT, and Wharton alums and have helped hundreds of clients add on average $100K and up to $1.7M to their compensation packages.

Read more from YourNegotiations.com Newsletter

Hi Reader, More from our Gentle Power Podcast conversation with Mia Smithson, a renowned tech industry recruiter who's interviewed more than 5000 people and hired more than 400. She shared some of her top tips in this past newsletter, where we covered why salary market data isn't helpful for negotiations and why whoever says the number first loses the negotiation. Today, we want to cover another question we always get: When the recruiter wants details about your other offer, how much should...

Hi Reader, Let’s say something uncomfortable happens at work or you’re seeing repeated incidents by a manager or co-workers that’s leaving you feeling off. You’re noticing off comments, inappropriate behavior, or in some cases, straight-up harassment or discrimination. You realize it might be important to document such cases, perhaps to protect yourself in the event you have a contentious departure from the company. But what are you legally allowed to do? Can you screenshot a Slack thread, or...

Hi Reader, This week on the Gentle Power Podcast (gentlepowerpodcast.com), we sat down with Mia Smithson, a renowned tech industry recruiter who has interviewed more than 5,000 people and hired more than 400. Amongst many achievements throughout her career, Mia joined a startup as its founding recruiter when it was around 50 people and helped grow it to a workforce of 700 across seven countries. Today, she is recruiting at a frontier AI company that hires 30 to 50 people every month. In this...